Political Promise

That Cold… War Feeling

In Garreth Matthews on December 6, 2010 at 4:44 pm

Skirmishes between South Korea and North Korea? Potential Russian intervention? Snow and ice? Must be a cold war, says Garreth Matthews.

The recent shelling of the South Korean border island of Yeonpyeong by the DPRK made me think back to the beginnings of the Cold War, and the Long Telegram written by George Kennan in 1946.  Kennan was the Deputy Chief of Mission to the USSR, working out of the US embassy in Moscow. In his 1946 telegram he responded to the State Departments query why the Soviets were not prepared to work with the World Bank and IMF, by detailing how the ‘Soviet Union did not see the possibility for long-term peaceful coexistence with the capitalist world’. Though his conclusions were stark he recommended a policy of containment, with an emphasis on a multifaceted diplomatic approach.

In 1949 Kennan’s Long Telegram would become the basis for the more ‘combatant’ NSC68. NSC68 was a National Security report headed by Paul Nitze, which used the evidence in the Long Telegram as justification for a complete reversal in US post-war policy. At the time Truman had been elected on a mandate of budget cuts, and reduced military spending, aimed at reducing the large deficit and encouraging business revival. Rather than reduce defence expenditure NSC68 recommended a much more aggressive and offensive fight against Communism in every part of the world, as well as the trebling of the defence budget at a time when the majority of Congress were fervently opposed to such measures.

Like most major foreign policy changes an international event would facilitate the introduction of what would become the Truman Doctrine; the 1950 Korean War. North Korean aggression supported by the Soviet Union was the perfect vehicle for Nitze to gain congressional support for NSC68. I recently met an academic who has spent many years surveying many members of the US government at that time. He proposed to me that what came out of many of those discussions was the possibility that the CIA had covertly encouraged sections of the DPRK regime to advance into the south, thereby creating the international conditions to further support for NSC68 at home.

Like most people I generally laugh off most conspiracy theories as the fodder that they are. However this meeting brought the current North Korea aggression back into my thoughts. Is it possible that like the 1950 war, the current North Korean encroachment over international boundaries, is being encouraged through back channels by the secret services of America in an effort to destabilise the whole South-East Asian region, thereby stalling the economic growth of the world’s next Superpower; China?

I am by no means advocating either theories regarding the 1950 Korean War or the current escalation in the area. However at the very least it poses food for thought.

  1. Conspiracy is a legitimate word in international relations. I think trendy media and maybe the X-Files ruined the seriousness of the word. People conspire. Intelligence networks when ordered definitely conspire.

    Your hunch that the recent aggression by North Korea being possible set-up, as in creating the conditions to provoke the North Korean to act as anticipated, is not far-fetched. We must not under-estimate American resources.

    North Korea is many things. It is one of few countries not conforming to the international arrangements where the US dominates or exerts great influence. Thus, they, well the people, pay the price i.e. famine and poverty. When a country wants to resist American influence, they better ought to devote all national resources and it probably for most countries like North Korea, still won’t be enough. However, here we are with the North Korean leadership doing it. The Americans have a lot of trump cards to play. The recent aggression by North Korea may be the anticipated actions within a wider stratagem. That is my suspicion. How it will play out, I’m don’t know, I might take a few guesses.

    Let us wind our clocks back to when the North sank that South Korean warship that ventured alarmingly close to North Korean shores. Again, that was a South Korean warship, not a yacht or pleasure cruise. What were they doing there? Drills? Ridiculous. Might as well send the Ark Royal (maybe a few months ago) near Hong Kong and do some drills, let’s see how the Communist Chinese react. That South Korean ship was that close to North Korean territory. Why?

    Maybe time is up for the North Korean regime. I think Beijing is calling it quits and perhaps is arranging their cards to not exactly complement Washington, but most certainly washing their hands of further North Korean surprises. The Communists in Beijing are to busy making money, consistent flare-ups is a nuisance and bad for business.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: